Buffalo Cheek Rolls vs. Other Chews: Which is Right for Your Dog?

Chewing is not just a fun activity for dogs; it's an essential part of their overall health regimen. From maintaining dental health to providing mental stimulation and aiding in behavior management, the right chew can make a world of difference in your dog's life. Among the plethora of options available to pet owners, buffalo cheek rolls have emerged as a standout choice.


In this blog, we'll explore what makes buffalo cheek rolls a preferred option and how they stack up against other common chews.

Understanding Dog Chews

Categories of Dog Chews

Dog chews can broadly be categorized into three types: natural, synthetic, and edible chews. Natural chews are derived from animal parts, such as bones or tendons; synthetic chews are manufactured from materials like nylon or rubber; and edible chews are consumable treats designed to be both tasty and beneficial for dental health.

Purpose of Dog Chews

The benefits of dog chews extend far beyond keeping your furry friend occupied. They play a crucial role in promoting dental health by reducing plaque and tartar buildup, strengthen jaw muscles, and alleviate boredom or anxiety, potentially preventing destructive behaviors.

Spotlight on Buffalo Cheek Rolls

What Are Buffalo Cheek Rolls?

Buffalo cheek rolls are made from the cheek muscle of buffalo, dried or lightly processed to create a chewy treat. Their natural composition and processing make them a unique option, offering a blend of nutrition and durability that is not commonly found in other chews.

Nutritional Benefits

Rich in high-quality protein and low in fat, buffalo cheek rolls are not only a delicious treat but also provide essential nutrients. They are highly digestible, reducing the risk of gastrointestinal upset, and are a natural source of important vitamins and minerals that support overall health.

Comparing Buffalo Cheek Rolls to Other Popular Dog Chews

Rawhide Chews

Rawhide chews, long a go-to for pet owners seeking to keep their dogs engaged, come with a host of issues that have raised concerns among veterinarians and canine nutritionists. The primary risks associated with rawhide include choking hazards and intestinal blockages resulting from large, undigested pieces. Additionally, the production of rawhide chews often involves chemical treatments to clean and preserve the hides, introducing potentially harmful substances into your dog’s diet. Buffalo cheek rolls emerge as a superior alternative, boasting higher digestibility and being free from harmful chemical additives. Their natural processing ensures that your dog can enjoy their chew without the risk of ingesting toxic residues, making buffalo cheek rolls a safer, healthier choice.

Synthetic Chews

Synthetic chews, made from materials like nylon, rubber, or plastic, are engineered for durability, offering dogs hours of chewing time. However, this longevity comes at a cost. These chews lack the nutritional benefits inherent in natural chews like buffalo cheek rolls. While synthetic options may not directly contribute to your dog’s nutritional profile, buffalo cheek rolls are rich in proteins and essential nutrients, contributing positively to their overall health. Furthermore, there’s a risk of ingestion of small pieces from synthetic chews, which can lead to gastrointestinal obstruction or other health issues. In contrast, buffalo cheek rolls, being fully digestible, minimize the risk of such complications, providing a blend of safety and nutrition.

Bully Sticks

Bully sticks, typically made from the dried, cooked, or smoked penis of a bull, which can be a rich source of protein but higher in fat compared to buffalo cheek rolls. They are highly palatable and digestible but can sometimes be high in calories, posing a risk of weight gain if not moderated. They are generally safe and digestible, but some dogs may experience an upset stomach, especially if they consume too much due to the higher fat content and their odor can be strong and unpleasant, particularly when wet, which may be a consideration for indoor use.

Buffalo cheek rolls offer more extended chewing satisfaction compared to soft chews like bully sticks and may be more suitable for dogs with dietary sensitivities due to their leaner protein and lower fat content. They tend to have less odor compared to bully sticks, making them more palatable for indoor use.


Antlers, while long-lasting, pose a risk of dental fractures due to their hardness. Additionally, they can lack uniformity in nutritional content and digestibility. Buffalo cheek rolls, on the other hand, strike a balance between durability and safety. They are generally softer than antlers, reducing the risk of dental damage. Moreover, buffalo cheek rolls provide a consistent nutritional profile, offering a reliable source of protein and other nutrients. Their digestibility ensures that dogs can enjoy the benefits of a satisfying chew without the risk of gastrointestinal issues common with harder, less digestible options.

Yak Milk Chews (YMCs)

Buffalo Cheek Rolls:

High in protein and essential nutrients, offering substantial health benefits.

Fully digestible, minimizing the risk of gastrointestinal issues.

Yak milk chews are made from yak and cow milk, offering a rich source of calcium and protein. They can last from several days to weeks, providing long-term chewing satisfaction.

Some dogs may attempt to swallow large pieces as the chew softens, which could pose a choking hazard or lead to intestinal blockage. Buffalo cheek rolls are also high in protein and essential nutrients, offering substantial health benefits. They are also fully digestible, minimizing the risk of gastrointestinal issues. They are generally safer as they pose less risk of large pieces being swallowed.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Dog Chews

When selecting the perfect chew for your furry friend, several factors should guide your decision to ensure both enjoyment and safety.

Dog's Size and Chew Style

The size and chewing behavior of your dog are critical in choosing the right chew. Larger breeds or aggressive chewers may need tougher, larger chews like buffalo cheek rolls, which can withstand rigorous chewing. Conversely, smaller breeds or gentle chewers might benefit from smaller, softer chews to prevent dental damage.

Allergies and Dietary Restrictions

Dogs with allergies or specific dietary restrictions need chews that align with their health requirements. Buffalo cheek rolls, being natural and single-ingredient, are less likely to trigger allergic reactions compared to chews with additives or multiple ingredients.

Safety and Quality

Opting for chews that are low in risk for splintering or causing choking is paramount. Additionally, chews should be sourced from high-quality, natural ingredients to avoid the ingestion of harmful chemicals. Buffalo cheek rolls typically meet these criteria, offering a safe and healthy option for most dogs.

Pros and Cons of Buffalo Cheek Rolls


Nutritional Value: Buffalo cheek rolls are rich in protein and essential nutrients, supporting overall canine health.

Safety: Their natural composition and appropriate hardness make them a safer choice, reducing the risk of choking or gastrointestinal blockage.

Appeal to Dogs: Most dogs find buffalo cheek rolls highly palatable, ensuring they are both a treat and a beneficial chew.


Availability: Depending on your location, buffalo cheek rolls might not be as readily available as other chews.

Cost: They may be more expensive than some other chew options, although the benefits often justify the cost.

Buffalo cheek rolls stand out among various dog chew options for their nutritional value, safety, and appeal to dogs. When choosing the right chew for your dog, it's crucial to consider their size, chewing style, and any dietary restrictions they may have. Buffalo cheek rolls offer a commendable balance of durability, nutritional benefits, and safety, making them a superior choice for many pet owners.

We encourage dog owners to explore buffalo cheek rolls as a nutritious, satisfying, and safe chew option for their canine companions. By comparing them to other chews and weighing their advantages and disadvantages, it's clear that buffalo cheek rolls are a worthwhile addition to any dog's diet.

Have you introduced your dog to buffalo cheek rolls, or do you have other favorite chews? Share your experiences and insights in the comments below. If your dog has specific health concerns or dietary needs, we recommend consulting with your veterinarian before introducing new chews into their diet.

Choosing peaksNpaws for your buffalo cheek rolls means opting for unparalleled quality and commitment to your dog's health and happiness. Our buffalo cheek rolls are sourced from the finest, grass-fed buffalo, ensuring a natural, high-protein treat without any added chemicals or preservatives. With peaksNpaws, you're not just purchasing a chew; you're investing in a product that stands for sustainability, ethical sourcing, and nutritional excellence. Each roll is carefully prepared to preserve its natural benefits, providing your canine companion with a safe, digestible, and enjoyable chewing experience. Trust peaksNpaws to deliver buffalo cheek rolls that satisfy your dog's natural chewing instincts while contributing positively to their overall well-being. Choose peaksNpaws today, where quality meets canine satisfaction.

Back to blog