Antler Dog Chews vs. Rawhide Dog Chews: A Comparison

Searching for the perfect chew toy can be challenging for dog owners. Much like finding a needle in a haystack, it requires sifting through countless options to discover the one that best suits their furry friend's needs.

It's not just about the right size or texture, but also about safety, health benefits, and enjoyment for our canine companions. Among the myriad of options, antlers and rawhide chews emerge as popular contenders. While both have their advantages, let's delve deeper to see which of them might be the superior choice for your furry friend.

Understanding Dog Chew Needs is Key


Dogs have an innate need to chew. It’s not just a pastime, but a crucial activity for dental health and mental stimulation. Chewing helps keep their teeth clean, their jaws strong, and their minds engaged. When choosing a chew toy, consider factors like your dog’s size, age, chewing habits, and any health issues.

Overview of Antler Chews


Antler chews, sourced from naturally shed deer or elk antlers, are increasingly popular for good reason. They are known for their durability and minimal mess. Let’s break down their benefits:

Natural and Nutritious

Antlers are a natural source of minerals such as calcium, phosphorus, and magnesium, contributing to a dog’s nutritional needs.

Long-lasting and Safe

Unlike other chew options, antlers are incredibly durable. They don’t splinter easily, reducing the risk of choking and intestinal blockages. They are also less prone to quick wear and tear, making them a safe option for vigorous chewers.

Dental Health Benefits

The hard surface of antlers helps scrape off tartar and plaque from your dog’s teeth, promoting better oral health.

Overview of Rawhide Chews


Rawhide, made from the inner layer of cow or horse hides, is another common chew toy. Here’s what you need to know:

Flavorful but Risky

Dogs are often attracted to the flavor and texture of rawhide. However, these chews can pose several risks. They can break into pieces and cause choking or blockages. Furthermore, some rawhide chews are treated with chemicals during processing, raising concerns about their safety.

Digestive Issues

Rawhide is not easily digestible. Consumed in large pieces, it can lead to gastrointestinal blockages and other digestive issues.

Comparative Analysis: Antler vs. Rawhide


Safety and Health

When it comes to safety, antlers have a clear edge. They are less likely to break into dangerous pieces compared to rawhide. Rawhide’s risk of splintering and causing digestive problems makes it a less favorable choice for many pet owners.

Durability and Longevity

Antlers outshine rawhide in durability. They last significantly longer, providing more value for your investment. While rawhide chews may seem cheaper, their shorter lifespan and potential health risks may lead to higher costs in the long run.

Nutritional Value

Antlers provide more nutritional benefits than rawhide. The natural minerals in antlers contribute to a healthy diet, whereas rawhide offers little to no nutritional value.

Suitability for Different Dogs

Antlers are suitable for dogs of all sizes and ages, especially aggressive chewers. Rawhide, on the other hand, is often not recommended for puppies, senior dogs, or dogs with sensitive stomachs.

Environmental and Ethical Considerations

Antlers are a sustainable and ethical choice. They are harvested from naturally shed antlers, meaning no harm comes to the animals. Rawhide production, in contrast, can be less environmentally friendly and raises ethical concerns regarding animal treatment.



In the battle between antlers and rawhide chews, antler dog chews emerge as a superior choice for most dogs. Their safety profile, nutritional benefits, and durability make them a wise investment for pet owners. While rawhide chews might be tempting for their flavor and initial low cost, their potential health risks and environmental concerns are significant drawbacks.

As you ponder over the best chew option for your beloved dog, consider peaksNpaws antler dog chews. Not only are they safe and long-lasting, but they're also ethically sourced, ensuring no harm comes to wildlife. Their natural composition makes them an excellent choice for your dog's health and dental hygiene. Give peaksNpaws antlers a try and observe the difference they make in satisfying your dog’s chewing instincts. Here's to happy, healthy chewing for your canine companion!

Back to blog